Take a guess: Is the following a German fairy tale? Or is it a Taiwanese folktale?

Image: German flag

The Mute Girl

Once upon a time, a beautiful girl was born to a desperately impoverished family.

The impoverishment meant that the family could ill afford to keep the child. They were forced to give her up for adoption.

In her new home, the child’s adoptive mother was kind. She was well-fed, kept warm and felt loved. This lucky child was happy and everything was good.

There was, however, one absolute rule that the child was required to obey: In the centre of her new home, there was a mysterious room, which the girl was made to promise never to look inside.

One day, the girl’s adoptive mother went out on an errand. As the girl wandered about the house, she took notice of the forbidden chamber and she felt her curiosity grow.

She crept toward the door and attempted to push it open. When she did, a loud creaking noise was produced by the heavy door. This greatly frightened the girl and she immediately forced the door shut. At precisely that moment, her adoptive mother returned.

The mother interrogated and berated the young maiden, but no matter what, the girl refused to own up to her transgression.

Furious, the adoptive mother instructed the girl to leave. The girl was banished and alone in the wild. Paralyzed by her fear, the girl lost her ability to speak and became mute.

Photo: Misty forest

One day, a passing chieftain was struck by the banished maiden’s beauty.

He proposed to her, to which she accepted. She travelled to her husband’s village, settled into her new home and, a year later, a baby boy was born.

Soon after the birth of her son, however, her adoptive mother appeared before her. The maiden was asked once again if she had lied and broken her promise and, again, she denied it. As punishment, the newborn was taken from her.

The same thing happened in each of the next three years. Each time a child was born, the maiden would be interrogated by her mysterious adoptive mother. Each time, she would deny her transgression and be stripped of her newborn child. Eventually, noting the disappearing children, the villagers accused her of being a witch who devoured them.

Finally, in the fifth year, when the adoptive mother once again appeared, the maiden at last admitted to her wrongdoing. And just like that, she was forgiven and her dear children were restored to her.

Photo: Baby in a crib

Our Lady’s Child

This story is allegedly about the value of truthfulness and promotes a message of forgiveness and redemption—once an offender repents.

A reader familiar with the works of Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm—the Brothers Grimm—would undoubtedly recognize it as a version of the German fairy tale known as Our Lady’s Child.

Yet, the above story is actually called The Mute Girl and is found in the folklore of the indigenous Formosan Puyuma people of southern Taiwan.

The parallels are striking. The plot and message of the stories are virtually identical.

In the German story, the adoptive mother is the Virgin Mary and her home is Heaven. In the Puyuma story, the tribal chief who proposed to the heroine replaces a passing German prince. The two tales are undoubtedly related.

How can that be? How can a traditional European fairy tale have a near-perfect equivalent in the remote mountains of southern Taiwan on the other side of the world?

The above story reveals two intriguing insights into indigenous Taiwanese history and the nature of folklore in general.

Portraint: Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm
The Brothers Grimm—Jacob and Wilhelm—who collected and preserved German folk stories in their Grimm’s Fairy Tales.

Cultural Exchange: Taiwan’s European Past

Christianity arrived in Taiwan as early as the 1500s and is Taiwan’s oldest organized religion. European traders, colonists and missionaries were among the first outsiders to make contact with Taiwan’s ancient Formosan communities. Today, Taiwan’s Catholic Dioceses and the Presbyterian Church are the two most influential Christian communities on the island.

Christian Westerners were the first to write down, using the Latin alphabet, the Taiwanese language (known as the Pe̍h-ōe-jī script) and numerous native Formosan languages (such as the Atayalic languages). These effective and unique writing systems are still employed today in Taiwan.

Europeans also proselytized their faith among the indigenous populations—converting large numbers of natives to the Christian fold. Alongside traditional shamanistic beliefs and rituals, many indigenous Taiwanese today still practice forms of Christianity that incorporate some elements of their ancient traditions.

It is likely that during these cross-cultural interactions, European fairy tales were transformed into Formosan folktales.

German stories such as Our Lady’s Child probably found a willing audience among the indigenous Puyuma people of Taiwan and subsequently entered traditional Puyuma folklore. This, in turn, sheds light on the intriguing nature of folklore in general.

Folklore consists of tales and traditions of the people, passed from generation to generation largely through word of mouth. The transmission of these stories readily crosses linguistic, ethnic, cultural and political boundaries.

Stories considered unique to one community or culture are frequently found to have close equivalents in entirely different cultures. Popular fairy tales such as Cinderella, for example, are found not only in the folklore of Germany but also in those of France, Italy and even as far as Nepal and China. The Twelve Dancing Princesses are found in English and German anthologies, but strikingly similar stories have also been discovered in the folklore of India.

Traditional tales easily adapt themselves to the cultures of new peoples they encounter. They quickly become an essential member of their adoptive homes.

What is in Germany a fairy tale called Our Lady’s Child is in Taiwan The Mute Girl. The story’s European origin is impossible to deny, but neither is its essential place in the traditional folklore of Taiwan’s Puyuma people.

Photo: Small church
Posted by:The Island Folklore Society

A society for the collection, preservation, translation, promotion and celebration of Taiwanese Tales & Traditions. Visit islandfolklore.org to learn more.